28+ Best Sims 4 Pumpkin Recipes for Fall: Soups, Baked Goods, Lattes and More

Hey Simmers,

Fall is easily one of my favorite seasons to play through in The Sims 4. I love decorating my builds with pumpkins, switching my Sims into cozy outfits, and adding seasonal foods to make everything feel a little more autumnal. And obviously, you can’t have fall without pumpkin recipes.

So, I decided to round up some of my favorite Sims 4 pumpkin recipes for fall. There’s a little bit of everything on this list, including pumpkin pies, warm soups, bread, custard, chili, sweet treats, cocktails, and even Starbucks-inspired fall drinks.

I also tried to include recipes for different occasions. You’ll find cozy meals for quiet nights at home, desserts for your Harvestfest dinner table, and seasonal drinks to serve when your Sims have friends and family over.

Hopefully, you find a few new recipes to add to your Mods folder and plenty of delicious fall foods for your Sims to enjoy all season long.

RELATED POST: 15+ Best Sims 4 Pumpkin Patch CC Designs for Your Gameplay

Stuffed Peppers, Pumpkin Soup, and Baked Pumpkin Slices

Download: Stuffed Peppers, Pumpkin Soup, and Baked Pumpkin Slices

Stuffed Peppers, Pumpkin Soup, and Baked Pumpkin Slices are three custom recipes by Somik and Severinka. The pumpkin dishes are perfect for adding more seasonal meals to your fall gameplay.

The Pumpkin Soup comes served inside a hollowed-out pumpkin, which makes it such a cute option for an autumn dinner or Halloween party. This requires Cooking Skill Level 4 and serves up to eight Sims. Your Sim can prepare it with potatoes, pumpkin, and herbs when using the custom ingredient version.

The Baked Pumpkin Slices are a much simpler option, requiring only Cooking Skill Level 1 and one pumpkin. They come out of the oven as roasted pumpkin wedges with a dipping sauce on the side.

You’ll also get Stuffed Peppers with the download, which require Cooking Skill Level 4. All three recipes can serve up to eight Sims and can be added to restaurant menus.

You’ll need the S&S Cookbook and Get to Work for these recipes. The creator also includes separate EA and custom versions, so make sure you only install the version suited to your cooking setup.

Pumpkin Scones

Download: Pumpkin Scones

Pumpkin Scones are a cozy fall treat from TianaSims, made with pumpkin, flour, and egg. They’re shaped into chunky golden wedges with a sweet drizzle on top, making them perfect for breakfast, brunch, or an afternoon snack during the fall season.

Your Sim needs Baking Skill Level 2 to make them, and the recipe comes in a party size. It’s also vegetarian-safe and lactose-free.

You’ll need the latest version of the TianaSims Cookbook for this Sims 4 pumpkin recipe to work.

Baked Pumpkin Custard

Download: Baked Pumpkin Custard

Baked Pumpkin Custard is one of my favorite Sims 4 pumpkin fall recipes. The cozy fall dessert from Icemunmun is served inside adorable mini pumpkins with a creamy custard topping. This delicacy easily fits into a Harvestfest dinner, Halloween party, or any fall-themed family meal.

The recipe requires Gourmet Cooking Skill Level 6, and you can prepare a single or large serving. Optional ingredients include batter, flour, milk or eggs, pumpkin, and mascarpone cheese. It’s vegetarian-safe, and you can also add it to restaurant dessert menus if you have Dine Out.

You’ll need the latest version of Custom Food Interactions for the recipe to work, but the food itself is base-game compatible. Click on the attached link to access the optional requirements.

Pumpkin Stew – Custom Food Recipes

Download: Pumpkin Stew – Custom Food Recipes

Pumpkin Stew is a hearty fall recipe, perfect for cozy dinners, Halloween parties, and autumn family meals. The stew comes packed with pumpkin pieces and is served in a black cooking pot, so it looks right at home in a rustic fall kitchen.

Your Sim needs Cooking Skill Level 3 to prepare it from the Cook Dinner menu. You can make a single serving, family serving, or party-size portion. It’s vegetarian-safe, base-game compatible, works with the Simple Living lot challenge, and can also appear on restaurant menus.

You’ll need the creator’s Custom Food Enabler mod for the recipe to work.

To install:

• Download the recipe file and place it in your Mods folder.
• Download the creator’s Custom Food Enabler mod and add it to your Mods folder.
• Make sure Custom Content and Mods are enabled in your game options.
• Restart The Sims 4.
• Find Pumpkin Stew under the Cooking menu.

Pumpkin Millet Porridge – Custom Food Recipe

Download: Pumpkin Millet Porridge – Custom Food Recipe

Pumpkin Millet Porridge is a warm breakfast recipe by XiaoFuuu made with pumpkin, rice, and millet. It has a soft, creamy texture with chunks of pumpkin throughout, making it a nice option for those chilly fall mornings.

The recipe requires Homestyle Cooking Level 1 and makes 12 servings, so there’s plenty to feed a larger household or save for later.

Requirements:

• For Rent Expansion Pack
• Game version 1.122
• Latest Recipe Book Mod v26.05
• Latest FoodPack Script v1.4

This is one of those Sims 4 pumpkin recipes perfect for cold weather.

Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls

Download: Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls

Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls are a sweet fall breakfast recipe from AlwaysJustJay. They’re soft rolled pastries filled with pumpkin cinnamon filling and topped with pumpkin icing. I’d definitely add these to a cozy fall breakfast or Harvestfest morning menu. It’s one of those Sims 4 pumpkin recipes ideal for fall and autumn.

You can choose between a base-game version using Homestyle Cooking Level 3 or a baking version requiring Get to Work and Baking Level 3. Just install one version in your game.

The recipe uses flour or sugar, milk, pumpkin conserve, and prepared dough. You can make a single serving or party-size batch, and the rolls are vegetarian-safe.

You’ll also need the current Food Enabler Mod for the recipe to work.

Pumpkin Patch Spiced Soup

Download: Pumpkin Patch Spiced Soup

If you’re looking for Sims 4 pumpkin recipes with a magical twist, Pumpkin Patch Spiced Soup is a fun one to add to your fall gameplay. This custom soup comes with the Enchanted Pumpkin Patch Elixir buff and several supernatural gameplay effects.

Depending on your packs, eating the soup can boost Spellcaster and Werewolf skills, temporarily transform Sims into scarecrows, remove curses and illnesses, unlock new traits, and grant supernatural perks. You can prepare single, medium, or large servings once you reach Homestyle Cooking Level 8.

The soup is vegetarian-safe and can also appear as a main meal in Dine Out restaurants. You’ll need Realm of Magic, Werewolves, Seasons, and Paranormal Stuff to access its full effects. There’s also a base-game version, but it won’t include the special effects.

RELATED POST: Best Sims 4 Supernatural CC: Witches, Demons, Magic & Paranormal Gameplay

Heart Breaker Cakes

Download: Heart Breaker Cakes

Heart Breaker Cakes are heart-shaped desserts from AlwaysJustJay, and the Pumpkin Spice Heart Cake is a cute option for your fall saves. It comes decorated with warm orange frosting, piped details, and little pumpkin accents around the top.

These are fully functional cakes, so you can use them as birthday or wedding cakes instead of treating them as single dessert pieces. You can also prepare a full party-size cake or a single serving.

There are two versions available: a base-game Homestyle Cooking version and a Baking version requiring Get to Work. Remember to only install one version in your game. The cakes are vegetarian-safe and work with Simple Living, Dine Out restaurant menus, Group Cooking, and Home Chef Hustle.

You’ll need the creator’s current Food Enabler Mod for the Sims 4 pumpkin recipes to work.

Pumpkin Buns – Bread Recipe

Download: Pumpkin Buns – Bread Recipe

Pumpkin Buns are adorable pumpkin-shaped bread rolls designed to fit perfectly on the table for a cozy fall breakfast or Harvestfest dinner. You can serve them straight from the basket or let your Sims grab individual buns.

The recipe works off the grid and uses optional ingredients, so you can still make the buns without having everything on hand. Eating them also provides a Happy Bread buff.

You’ll need Littlbowbub’s Homestead Helper for this recipe to work. This recipe is compatible with the base game.

Iced Pumpkin Latte

Download: Iced Pumpkin Latte

Iced Pumpkin Latte is a refreshing fall drink for Sims who want their pumpkin fix without a hot cup of coffee. It combines pumpkin with milk for a creamy seasonal drink and only requires Cooking Level 1, so practically any Sim can make it.

Your Sims can prepare the latte straight from the fridge through the Cold Drinks section of Grannies Cookbook. It comes as a single serving and is also available in restaurants. If you have the required extras, your Sims can order it from cafés or prepare it using the Home Barista Espresso Machine.

Click on the attached link to access the required mods to make this set work.

Pumpkin Cheese Burgers

Download: Pumpkin Cheese Burgers

Pumpkin Cheese Burgers are a fun autumn twist on the classic cheeseburger, with adorable pumpkin-shaped buns that instantly make the meal feel more seasonal. This is one of those Sims 4 pumpkin recipes I’d use for a fall cookout, Harvestfest gathering, or Halloween party.

The recipe makes a party serving of eight and is found under the BBQ menu. Your Sim only needs Cooking Level 2 to prepare it, and the required ingredients include meat, bread, and cheese. You can even cook the burgers off the grid, and they’re available to serve in restaurants.

You’ll need the newest version of Grannies Cookbook for this recipe to work. This custom food is base-game compatible.

Chicken Stir-Fry Pepper Pumpkins Recipe

Download: Chicken Stir-Fry Pepper Pumpkins Recipe

The Chicken Stir-Fry Pepper Pumpkin Recipe is a cute fall-inspired main dish made with orange bell peppers shaped to look like tiny pumpkins. Each pepper is stuffed with a savory mixture of rice, meat, and colorful vegetables, making it perfect for Harvestfest dinners, Halloween parties, or any autumn-themed meal.

Your Sim needs Homestyle Cooking Level 5 to prepare the dish. The recipe supports Simple Living and requires power to cook. The listed ingredients are optional, so you can still make the meal even if you don’t have all of them installed:

• Orange bell pepper
• Any wrapped white meat
• Dried rice grain
• Canned stir-fry

Using these ingredients reduces the cooking time. This recipe is also compatible with the base game.

Fancy Pumpkin Pie Recipe

Download: Fancy Pumpkin Pie Recipe

If you’re looking for a classic fall dessert with a prettier, more decorative finish, Fancy Pumpkin Pie Recipe is a lovely addition to your Sim’s seasonal menu. It’s made with pumpkin, cream, eggs, and warm pumpkin pie spices, creating a rich, smooth dessert for Harvestfest dinners, fall parties, or cozy family meals.

Your Sim needs Baking Level 1 to prepare the pie. The ingredients are optional, so the recipe can still be made without having every ingredient installed:

• Canned spiced pumpkin
• Cream
• Any eggs
• Pie dough

Note that this recipe is also Simple Living compatible and requires power to prepare.

Spiced Pumpkin Bread

Download: Spiced Pumpkin Bread

Spiced Pumpkin Bread is a warm fall-inspired loaf for adding some seasonal baking to your Sim’s kitchen. The recipe has a rich pumpkin look and can be served as a full loaf before being sliced into individual portions. I highly recommend adding this to your Sims 4 pumpkin recipes for fall.

Your Sim needs Baking Level 3 to make the bread, and it comes in a party serving size. The recipe uses:

• Any pumpkin
• Flour or sugar
• Egg

It’s vegetarian-safe and lactose-free. You’ll also need the latest version of TianaSims Cookbook and the Get to Work Expansion Pack for the Baking skill.

Pumpkin Pie Dip

Download: Pumpkin Pie Dip

Pumpkin Pie Dip is a fun fall snack for Sims who want something sweet without baking an entire pie. It combines creamy pumpkin dip with ginger snap cookies, apple slices, and graham crackers for dipping.

Your Sim only needs Homestyle Cooking Level 1 for this recipe, and you can make single, family, or party-sized servings. The required ingredients are:

• Apple
• Custard
• Pumpkin conserve

The recipe is vegetarian-safe and lactose-free, and it works with Simple Living, group cooking, restaurant menus, and off-the-grid gameplay. You’ll need the Food Enabler Mod for the recipe to work.

Pumpkin Spice Swiss Roll

Download: Pumpkin Spice Swiss Roll

Pumpkin Spice Swiss Roll is a cozy fall dessert that’s a great addition to your Sims 4 pumpkin recipes for fall. The gorgeous orange sponge is wrapped around a creamy swirl filling with little pumpkin and autumn leaf decorations. It’s cute for Harvestfest dinners, fall parties, or simply filling your Sim’s kitchen with seasonal treats.

Your Sim needs Homestyle Cooking Level 4 to make it, and the recipe comes in a party serving size. It uses:

• Any pumpkin
• Flour or sugar
• Milk or eggs
• Batter

The Pumpkin Spice Swiss Roll is vegetarian-safe and requires the latest version of TianaSims Cookbook to work.

Pumpkin Pie Martini

Download: Pumpkin Pie Martini

Pumpkin Pie Martini is a festive fall cocktail made with vodka, pumpkin puree, maple syrup, pumpkin spice, and cream, then finished with a sprinkle of cinnamon. The creamy orange drink looks especially cute served alongside your Sim’s Harvestfest dinner or at an autumn-themed party.

Your Sim needs Homestyle Cooking Level 2 to prepare the drink. It comes in party, family, and single-serving sizes and requires pumpkin and milk as ingredients.

The Pumpkin Pie Martini is vegetarian-safe and works with Simple Living, Dine Out restaurant menus, and Off-the-Grid gameplay. You’ll need the current Food Enabler Mod for the recipe to work.

Cream of Pumpkin Soup Recipe

Download: Cream of Pumpkin Soup Recipe

Cream of Pumpkin Soup Recipe is a warm, comforting fall meal made with pureed pumpkin, cream, vegetables, and spices. The creamy orange soup is served inside a white pumpkin bowl and topped with greens and a drizzle of cream. It’s one of the best Sims 4 pumpkin recipes for fall and autumn.

Your Sim needs Gourmet Cooking Level 3 to prepare the soup. The optional ingredients include:

• White heirloom pumpkin
• Any root vegetable
• Onion or garlic
• Any spice blend
• Cream
• Vegetable stock

The recipe falls under the Soup and Stew category and is designed as a cozy seasonal dish for fall. The ingredients are optional, so any custom ingredients you don’t have installed will simply be excluded from the recipe.

Pumpkin Soup Open

Download: Pumpkin Soup Open

Pumpkin Soup Open is a decorative bowl of pumpkin soup designed to add a warm, seasonal touch to your Sim’s kitchen or dining room. The soup comes inside a hollowed-out orange pumpkin with a spoon resting inside, making it a cute piece of food clutter for autumn kitchens or Halloween displays.

Unlike the functional Sims 4 pumpkin recipes on this list, this pumpkin soup is purely decorative, so your Sims can’t cook or eat it. It’s an easy way to make your fall food displays look fuller and more realistic without adding another functional recipe to your game.

Note that this recipe is part of a larger set found in the description.

Coconut Pumpkin Soup

Download: Coconut Pumpkin Soup

Coconut Pumpkin Soup is a warm and creamy custom meal that combines pumpkin and coconut for a cozy fall lunch. The finished dish is a vibrant orange soup topped with seasoning and served alongside slices of bread. It’s undoubtedly one of the best Sims 4 pumpkin recipes perfect for chilly autumn days in your game.

Your Sim only needs Level 1 Cooking Skill to prepare the soup, so it’s an easy recipe to add to almost any household. You can make either a single serving or a larger eight-serving portion for the whole family.

The optional ingredients are coconut and any pumpkin, and you’ll find the recipe under the Lunch category. You’ll also need the latest version of Balkanika’s Keto Cookbook for the recipe to work.

Pumpkin Chili Recipe

Download: Pumpkin Chili Recipe

Pumpkin Chili Recipe is a hearty custom meal made with tender pumpkin chunks, juicy tomatoes, black beans, and a blend of warm spices. It has a rich, smoky flavor and is served inside a hollowed-out pumpkin, which makes the presentation perfect for cozy fall dinners or a Harvestfest feast.

Your Sim needs Level 3 Homestyle Cooking Skill to prepare this dish. The optional ingredients include:

• Orange heirloom pumpkin
• Any tomato
• Any spice
• Black beans

Remember, if you’re using the creator’s Waste Not lot challenge, your Sim will also receive pumpkin seeds after preparing the recipe.

Pumpkin Pie with Walnut & Maple Cream

Download: Pumpkin Pie with Walnut & Maple Cream

Pumpkin Pie with Walnut & Maple Cream is a delicious fall dessert topped with chopped walnuts and a rich maple cream. The creamy pumpkin filling, crunchy walnut topping, and sweet maple flavor make this a great option for Harvestfest dinners, autumn parties, or simply adding more seasonal desserts to your Sim’s kitchen.

Your Sim needs Level 8 Cooking Skill to prepare the pie, and it comes in party, family, and single-serving sizes. The ingredients are optional, so your Sim can still make the recipe without having them in their inventory.

You’ll need the Recipes Enabler v1.4 or newer for this custom recipe to work in-game.

Sweet Potato Pumpkin Pie

Download: Sweet Potato Pumpkin Pie

Sweet Potato Pumpkin Pie is a cozy seasonal dessert combining sweet potato and pumpkin into one rich, creamy pie. It’s topped with dollops of cream for a simple homemade finish. This is a great choice for Harvestfest, fall family dinners, or even Winterfest celebrations.

Your Sim needs Level 3 Cooking Skill to prepare the pie, and it comes in a party serving size. The recipe is vegetarian-safe and can also appear on restaurant menus. Ingredients are optional, so you can still prepare it without having everything on hand.

You’ll need the newest version of Grannies Cookbook installed for this recipe to work in-game.

Pumpkin Spice Punch

Download: Pumpkin Spice Punch

Pumpkin Spice Punch is a refreshing fall drink made with pumpkin, cinnamon, and nutmeg. It’s served from a large punch bowl decorated with colorful pumpkins and cinnamon sticks.

This non-alcoholic drink is served cold and gives Sims the Punchy Pumpkin buff. Spellcasters also receive a boost to their XP and charge after drinking it. Your Sim needs Level 7 Homestyle Cooking Skill to prepare the punch.

The recipe is base-game compatible, and the pumpkin, cinnamon, and nutmeg ingredients are optional. You’ll need the creator’s Custom Drink Interaction mod for the Pumpkin Spice Punch to work in-game.

Starbucks Fall Drinks Collection

Download: Starbucks Fall Drinks Collection

Starbucks Fall Drinks Collection is a cute seasonal set for bringing those classic coffee-shop fall vibes into your game. The collection includes four Starbucks-inspired drinks, with whipped cream, caramel drizzle, and branded cups that look great in cozy autumn screenshots, cafés, kitchens, or coffee shop builds.

The collection includes:

• Pumpkin Spice Latte
• Salted Caramel Mocha
• Pumpkin Cream Cold Brew
• Salted Caramel Mocha drink variation

The drinks are decorative objects rather than functional beverages, but the set also comes with accessory versions your Sims can hold. The accessories are base-game compatible, available for Sims aged teen to elder, and come in hat and ring versions.

You’ll also get three single poses designed for use with the drinks. To use the included pose pack, you’ll need Pose Player and the Teleport Any Sim mod.

FAQ

Can my Sims actually cook these pumpkin recipes?

Most of the recipes on this list are functional custom foods your Sims can prepare and eat. However, a few entries are decorative food or drink CC, so always check the creator’s description before downloading.

Do I need additional mods for these pumpkin recipes to work?

Some recipes require additional mods or custom food systems, such as a recipe enabler, cookbook, custom food interaction, or drink interaction mod. I recommend downloading every requirement listed by the creator to ensure the recipe works properly in-game.

Why isn’t a downloaded pumpkin recipe appearing in my Sim’s cooking menu?

First, make sure you’ve installed all required files and supporting mods. Some recipes also require a specific Cooking, Gourmet Cooking, or Homestyle Cooking skill level before they appear.

Are there both sweet and savory pumpkin recipes on this list?

Yes. There are plenty of sweet options like pumpkin pie, pumpkin bread, custard, and other desserts, alongside savory dishes such as pumpkin soup and pumpkin chili.

Are there pumpkin drinks for The Sims 4?

Yes. I’ve included several seasonal drinks, including pumpkin-inspired cocktails, punch, and coffee-shop-style fall drinks.

Can I use these recipes for Harvestfest?

Absolutely. Pumpkin pies, warm soups, seasonal drinks, and other autumn dishes work especially well for creating a larger Harvestfest meal for your Sims.

Do custom Sims 4 recipes require ingredients?

It depends on the creator. Some recipes have optional ingredients, while others may integrate with systems such as Simple Living and require your Sim to have certain ingredients available.

Can toddlers eat these custom pumpkin foods?

Some creators specifically make their recipes toddler-friendly, but this varies between downloads. Check the individual recipe details if you want something the entire Sim family can eat.

Can I serve these recipes at a fall party?

Yes. Many of the recipes come with family or party-size servings, making them useful for Harvestfest dinners, Halloween parties, family gatherings, and other autumn events.

Are there vegetarian pumpkin recipes available?

Yes. Several recipes featured on this list are marked vegetarian-safe by their creators. Check each download page for dietary information before adding a recipe to your game.

What should I do if a custom pumpkin recipe stops working after a Sims 4 update?

Check the creator’s page for an updated version of the recipe and any supporting food mods it requires. Major game patches can sometimes affect custom recipes or the scripts and interactions they rely on.

Can I use several custom pumpkin recipes at the same time?

Yes. You can build a much larger custom food menu by installing several recipes, provided you also have their individual requirements installed correctly.

Conclusion

And that wraps up my favorite Sims 4 pumpkin recipes for fall!

I tried to include enough variety here so you’re not stuck making pumpkin pie over and over again. You can serve your Sims warm pumpkin soup on a chilly evening, bake something sweet for Harvestfest, make a cozy fall drink, or put together an entire pumpkin-themed dinner.

I especially like using custom recipes when I’m playing through seasonal holidays because the food makes the celebration feel much more intentional. Add a few pumpkins around the house, light some candles, dress everyone in their coziest fall outfits, and you’ve pretty much got the perfect Harvestfest setup.

I hope you found a few new recipes worth adding to your game. Happy fall, Simmers!